Link to us from your website and promote the community!... Then email us to receive a Free CNC cheat sheet from the CNC Specialty Store!

Facebook Group

Share your CNC information?
...Macro programs
...and more

Suggestions or comments?
Please Email Us

Thank you for all your contributions and supporting the CNC community.

Fixture design and work holding considerations

Fixtures should be made by a reputable fixture builder. This is worth the cost especially if it is beyond a simple work holding fixture. Things to consider are the number of hydraulic circuits and fixture sequencing. I recommend doing all sequencing of hydraulic valves integrated directly in the fixture if possible. Especially when multiple fixtures or jobs are used with one hydraulic unit package. This way the hydraulic and PLC programming can remain the same and be the most versatile for any new or existing jobs you may want to run in the future. In a horizontal machining center application this cuilt in fixture sequencing is most commonly used. This becomes even more critical in applications in which it may be difficult to run multiple hydraulic lines out to each of the pallets. The main drawback for putting the valving on each fixture is the costs for additional valving and design involved. When horizontal machining centers with palllet changers are used, you may be able to save on the inital quote for integrations which may help compensate for the other additional costs. Single pallet machines have many more options for how you can configure the hydraulic system and the least restrictions for any type of automation. They are also the easiest to integrate and less costly to for turnkey automation. There are generally two types of pallet changers to consider a side by side shuttle or a rotary type pallet changer.

Single pallet machine:

The hydraulics, pneumatics and electrical wires going to the fixture can very easily be draped down to the table. They give you the most automation options possible.

Shuttle type side by side pallet changer and work holding:

Integrating shuttle type pallet changers is often difficult when running more than two hydraulic lines. Reason being is there is usually some type of cable track to move the hoses, electrical, and pneumatic lines in and out. This sometimes requires extensive machine modification. Another problem is that in order to get the cable track to move the full length of the machine tool, it must float in mid air. Doing so it is only supported by the cable track construction itself.

The main fixture work holding problems and considerations with shuttle type of pallet changer are:

  • Two hydraulics lines maximum, preferably 1 line for single acting fixture
  • If robot load- preferably double acting clamps for confirmation of actual clamp positions incase of single actuating clamp malfunction. If clamp unclamp cycle is interrupted there may be some low pressure still being held by P.O. check valve.
  • Hydraulic clamp sequencing must be built into the fixture itself
  • Preferably P.O. checks on A and B if robot load. Single if no robot load
  • Very easy to interface electrical components into fixture if needed

Rotary type pallet changers and fixtures:

Rotary pallet changers can also be a challenge and pretty costly typically from $12,000 to $28,000 for a complete hydraulic clamping system. These type of systems will generally require a rotary union directly in the center of the pallet changers rotation. Some applications do not require a rotary union as they are only able to rotate 180 degrees. These systems will have hoses that rotate 180 degrees with the table. Even in these circumstances a rotary union is preferred. Many times if a pallet changer looses position or zero return. The machine is capable of rotating 360 Degrees. So for extra protection this type is always safest. Some machines are impossible to use a rotary union. As always sequencing valves on the fixture are preferred. Also, if part present air circuit is required then you will need 2 more ports in the rotary union for this option.

Why will it be more costly? What are the drawbacks?

  • Costs of custom rotary unions are often needed if exceeding 6 pass. Mounting area in machine tool may be limited.
  • Higher costs of integrating the package to the machine.
  • If sequencing is done at fixture, all clamping circuits will be the same and ladder logic does not have to be rewritten for different fixtures.

Other fixture considerations:

Part present circuit- Usually the best practice is to add a part present circuit with air not electrically. Electrical components in the machining area will often cause problems. Coolants tend to eat up seals and have chemical reactions with electrical components.